Mary Cosby Meredith Jen
Photo Credit: Thomas Cooper/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

Mary Cosby Questions Meredith Marks’ Decision To Forgive Jen Shah 

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 5 has come to an end, and we’re already missing our messy snowflake holders. The last episode of the three-part reunion continued to deliver when it came to unpacking the drama. Of course, the ladies discussed the dramatic table text read during the finale and beyond. Meredith Marks, in particular, revealed some shocking news.

During Part 3 of RHOSLC’s reunion, Meredith revealed that she received a call from Jen Shah from prison. “It was very brief, she called me. Well, obviously I can’t call her,” Meredith said. Obviously, her co-stars had a lot to say.

Whitney Rose didn’t understand how that wasn’t just as bad, if not worse, than her reaching out to Monica Garcia. “I didn’t seek Jen out to dig dirt on my friends. Jen called me from prison after she’s taken accountability, served time and is paying restitution,” Meredith added. However, Whitney and other stars like Mary Cosby did not agree.

Mary Cosby isn’t down for Jen Shah’s redemption

@bravotv

Meredith’s controversial phone call, explained. The #RHOSLC Reunion concludes on February 5th! #MeredithMarks #WhitneyRose #MaryCosby #RealHousewivesOfSaltLakeCity

♬ original sound – Bravo

When Whitney said that Jen traumatized the RHOSLC cast more than Monica, Mary chimed in to agree. “If Jen Shah called me, I would not accept her call. She tormented us,” Mary said.

Meredith asked what to do moving forward with Jen, and Mary thinks she needs to stay far away. “She lied,” Mary said. “She really mistreated your kids. And you.”

Meredith agreed but asked if there are no second chances in life. Mary believes there are – just not in Jen’s case. “Some people just go too far and she’s one of them. She lied all the way up to the day she couldn’t,” Mary said.

It doesn’t seem like anyone from this crew will be joining Meredith for Jen’s welcome home party after her prison sentence.

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 5 is available to stream on Peacock.

TELL US – WERE YOU SURPRISED THAT JEN CALLED MEREDITH? DO YOU AGREE WITH MARY THAT SHE SHOULDN’T HAVE ANSWERED?

X