Heather Gay has received much praise from fans since the start of the new year. Following the Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 4 finale, Heather’s noteworthy monologue has been recited, danced to, and analyzed by stars all over, including Kevin Hart, Jennifer Lawrence, and Valentin Chmerkovskiy from Dancing with the Stars.
After discovering that her co-star, Monica Garcia, was behind the troll account Reality Von Tease, Heather went berzerk, slamming her with “receipts, proof, screenshots,” and so much more. While going off on Monica, Jen Shah’s former assistant, Heather also revealed a shocking truth about her mystery black eye from Season 3.
“I went on book tour and defended [Jen], and took shit for the fact that she gave me a black eye,” the Bad Mormon author told her castmates. However, there’s another Real Housewives star who finds her story fishy. Yup, the OC’s Tamra Judge. Keep reading to find out why.
Tamra isn’t buying anything Heather Gay is selling…
When Heather revealed her black eye during the Season 3 cast trip, everybody was shocked. But the most bizarre part of the storyline was that she couldn’t remember how it happened. Then, after Jen was sent away to begin her six-year prison sentence for fraud, she magically remembered. Although some RHOSLC fans were satisfied with Heather’s answer, many were not.
During a recent episode on their podcast, Tamra and Teddi Mellencamp shared their theory of why they don’t buy Heather’s story about her injury.
“If you look at the first day of her filming [the Season 3 cast trip], she had the semblance of a black eye starting,” Tamra said before Teddi pointed to a photo of Heather and asked listeners to “be the judge.”
“It takes a while for a black eye to turn black like that,” Tamra said. “I don’t think we’re ever going to get a true answer from her.” That’s something Dorinda Medley also pointed out, after Heather’s supposed revelation.
Whew. Tamra and Teddi could certainly be on to something with that revelation. Plus, based on Heather’s actions so far, fans aren’t sure they can trust her anyway. So, if the T’s theory is true, it would surprise no one.
The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City is available to stream on Peacock.
TELL US — DO YOU BELIEVE HEATHER? DO YOU THINK JEN GAVE HER A BLACK EYE?
